A central theme of the book is the infamous case (1976), also known as the "Habeas Corpus" case. During the Indian Emergency, the majority of the bench ruled that fundamental rights could be suspended. Justice Khanna was the lone dissenter , famously stating that even during an emergency, the state does not have the power to deprive a person of life or liberty without the authority of law.
Neither Roses Nor Thorns : The Legacy of Justice H.R. Khanna is the autobiography of Justice Hans Raj Khanna , one of the most revered figures in Indian judicial history. First published in 1985 by Eastern Book Company , the book provides a personal and professional chronicle of a man who famously chose judicial integrity over the highest office in the Indian judiciary. Overview of the Autobiography
His resignation, tenure as Chairman of the Law Commission, and a brief three-day stint as a Union Minister. Book Review: Neither Roses Nor Thorns By H.R. Khanna neither roses nor thorns pdf
His courage earned him international acclaim, with The New York Times suggesting that a monument should be erected in his honor. Key Themes and Structure
Influences from his father and grandmother in Amritsar. A central theme of the book is the
As a result of this stance, Justice Khanna was superseded for the post of Chief Justice of India by the Indira Gandhi government.
The book is structured into short, manageable chapters that cover various phases of his life and career: Neither Roses Nor Thorns : The Legacy of Justice H
Details on the Kesavananda Bharati case (Basic Structure Doctrine) and the Kalka Firing Enquiry .
The book is more than a simple memoir; it is a reflection on the , the independence of the judiciary, and the moral courage required to uphold constitutional values. Justice Khanna, described as a "poet at heart," uses a simple and lucid style to narrate his journey from an assistant advocate in Amritsar to a judge of the Supreme Court of India . The Landmark "Habeas Corpus" Dissent
Select the option that works best for you.
All plans include full access to the Masterclass.
One-time Pament
Pay once and save $205
2 Payments
Pay 50% now, 50% in one year
USD 817
(1,632 total)
Pay per unit (every 2 weeks)
52 units in total. Cancel anytime.
USD 34.7
(1,804 total)
Monthly plan
4 years in total. Cancel anytime.
USD 34.7
(1,804 total)